Mr. Sardonicus (1961)
A search for a winning lottery ticket in his dead father's grave causes Sardonicus' face to freeze in a horrible grimace, until he forces a doctor to treat his affliction--with even more grotesque results! The audience gets an opportunity to vote--via the "Punishment Poll"--for the penalty Sardonicus must pay for his deeds... mask, leech, grave, castle, baron, flashback, torture, masked man, disfigured face, disfigurement, 19th century